Gilgamesh is the king [...], When the clay tablets of the epic of Gilgamesh were first discovered and translated in 1872, scholars quickly noticed striking similarities between its narratives and those of the bible (Coogan 68). It is interesting to read something that [...], Among the numerous struggles humans undergo within a lifetime, the ultimate struggle of the human experience is to eventually contend with mortality. This writer’s research question is this: what is the relationship between the flood accounts of the Gilgamesh Epic and Genesis? We will send an essay sample to you in 2 Hours. In Gilgamesh the gods saw the uproar of mankind and decided to exterminate them. In both stories, the higher power assigns a man to build this ark and lead a new world with his animals. This is very different from The Book of Genesis. In the Gilgamesh Epic, it is obvious that Enlil, who mainly decreed the flood, is not omnipotent or omniscient because a fellow god Ea thwarted him. Genesis and Gilgamesh: Comparing and Contrasting. PhDessay is an educational resource where over 1,000,000 free essays are collected. Original Question: What are some of the main differences between the flood in the Epic of Gilgamesh Tablet XI and the Genesis flood? While reading Gilgamesh, I was struck by the similarities between the story being told and that of the stories compiled within the Bible. This is important because it shows that not even God or gods can achieve perfection, and humans certainly cannot. In The Book of Genesis, it says: “rain fell upon the earth forty days and forty nights" (Gen. 7:12). Parallels Between the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible The most well-known parallel between the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible is the story of the Flood, in Genesis 6-7. Epic Of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh, Hero, Mythology, Warrior Ethos in the Tale of Sohrab and the Epic of Gilgamesh, Comparability of the Floods: how the Epic of Gilgamesh Relates and Conflicts the Bible, Parallels between the Gilgamesh Surge Account and the Scriptural Surge Account, The Role of Women in the Epic of Gilgamesh. Answer: The Enuma Elish, or the “Seven Tablets of Creation,” is a Babylonian creation myth that has a number of literary and cultural connections to the creation account in Genesis 1. There are many similarities between the Noah flood story and the Gilgamesh flood story. The gods in the stories want the best for all of their creation, but when disobeyed, can be harsh. 16 students ordered this very topic and got original papers. In both accounts, samples from all species of … In Genesis, God notices that man has become sinful and wicked in their actions and their thoughts. Like the flood story, it seems that Genesis is in dialogue with an older Mesopotamian tradition. The flood is a major connection between The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis. Orders:17 The obvious similarities between The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Book of Genesis tell us that the people of the world coming from different cultures still have many mutual beliefs. A major difference among the stories was, in the book of Genesis there is only one God, and God is the creators of all things; (Genesis chpt 1&2). The epic of Gilgamesh makes reference to the Enuma Elish, because both stories include gods and heroes. Prostitutes are also seen as mystical and powerful. In Gilgamesh, the divine assembly find … The reason for sending the flood is not explained in Gilgamesh (excessive violence in Genesis) The flood is ultimately condemned as a murderous mistake in Gilgamesh. For example, Ishtar seems to act totally out of selfishness when Gilgamesh rejects her. Tabl. In The Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh sleeps with all of the women in the town that he rules. The correlations between the two made me question whether or not Gilgamesh somehow influenced the creation of certain narratives within the religion I practice today. https://phdessay.com/the-book-of-genesis-vs-the-epic-of-gilgamesh/, Similarities In the Epic of Gilgamesh and Siddhartha, Personal Transformation from Gilgamesh to Chihiro, The Epic of Gilgamesh: Values, & Serpents vs. Bible. The flood in both stories destroys most of creation. In the two [...], Men always are symbol of power and change but women have played a crucial role through the history. Both stories reveal that gods will not hesitate to implement strict punishments if they feel that their subjects are out of line. The stories send a clear message that humans are above animals and humans have power over all animals. Overall, this tale makes sex out to be a spiritual, powerful, and pleasurable action. Humans respect their god(s), but sometimes disobey them. In Genesis there is one main God who was worshiped and listened to when given instructions. Flood Essay The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis are ancient texts that were widely read and are continually examined today. The Epic of Gilgamesh, a literary product of Mesopotamia, contains many of the same themes and motifs as the Hebrew Bible. Retrieved from https://phdessay.com/the-book-of-genesis-vs-the-epic-of-gilgamesh/, The Book of Genesis vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh. However, in The Book of Genesis, God does not give anyone the gift of immortality. Satan as the Hero of Paradise Lost Satan Arousing the Rebel Angels, William Blake (1808) Leontien Kouwenhoven 1260707 Supervisor: Dr. J. R. Veenstra Second Reader: Prof. Dr. A. Haven’t found the relevant content? This is essentially equivalent to the story that Utnapishtim, the Sumerian Noah, tells to Gilgamesh on Tablet XI. A lot of the old testament seems to focus the on good and evil in the world and how God responded to it. But you can one from professional essay writers. God saw wickedness and evil in mankind and decided to destroy them. Hire a subject expert to help you with The Book of Genesis vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh. Two Different Books with Similar Stories The Book of Genesis and The Epic of Gilgamesh have many clear similarities. The second bird sent is a swallow in Gilgamesh and a dove in Genesis. Between The Epic of Gilgamesh and the creation, destruction, and renewal of the world in the bible in Genesis chapters 1-8, which similarities do the stories have?. Unlike The Gilgamesha where the reason was never said however the sender of the flood was a secret council of gods the idea was brought up by Enlil , the god of earth wind and air. An essential difference between the Gilgamesh Epic and Genesis is that the former is a polytheistic mythology, whereas the latter is based on a monotheistic theology. This is proven in one of the oldest stories ever. Kings can obtain as much physical power as they and their subjects have at hand, however even the most powerful of kings are subject to the brutal cycles of the most natural regulators. The gods in Gilgamesh make an error sending the flood to exterminate mankind and try to atone for it by making Utnapishtim and his wife immortal so that humanity is never in danger of extinction again. Biblical writers probably knew of the much older flood but revised it so that it fit with their own history and worldview. From the Epic, Enkidu is a wild man created by the gods as Gilgamesh’s peer to relieve him from oppression caused by the people of Uruk. The Book of Genesis vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh. What Are The Similarities Between Genesis And The Gilgamesh Compare And Contrast The Epic Of Gilgamesh. The final difference between the flood in Gilgamesh and the flood in Genesis is the ending scene of the story, the last interaction between the survivor and his God(s). As Genesis continues we see mankind becoming more evil and God plans to destroy everything he created. 48 Vitosha Boulevard, ground floor, 1000, Sofia, Bulgaria Bulgarian reg. However, there are some significant differences between the two accounts. The purpose of Gilgamesh is to show people how making selfish, rash decisions never work out the way you intend them to. The differences between Hebrew and Babylonian cultures that these stories suggest is that what people want as a reward is different. Through this study, this research question is investigated by comparing five perspectives of these two accounts. In conclusion, the gods act like parent figures who know what is best for their subjects. 2020 © StudyDriver.com - Big database of free essay examples for students at all levels. As we saw with Genesis 1 and Enuma Elish, Genesis 2-9 and Atrahasis breathe the same air. Personal Transformation from Gilgamesh to Chihiro Regardless of the setting and the time, maturity and development are key processes that reshape individual’s character. This is very different from The Epic of Gilgamesh in which Gilgamesh sleeps with many women while unwed. It is clear that the people of the ancient world believed that the world was created by a higher power in a number of days, that a higher power created the human race, humans are very flawed, and many other mutual beliefs that can be found in The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Book of Genesis. Although there are very major similarities between The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Book of Genesis, there are also many differences. Genesis And Genesis In The Epic Of Gilgamesh. In The Book of Genesis, sex is not for pleasure. They share ancient Mesopotamian ways of talking about origins. Download file to see previous pages The King lived approximately between 2750 and 2500 BCE. Comparing the flood narrative in Gilgamesh to the biblical flood in Genesis "is an area of scholarship that has attracted more attention than pretty much anything else in the history of Assyriology," says Pryke. Comparisons between Genesis, Gilgamesh and Metamorphoses. In Gilgamesh, a dove is sent out first, whereas in Genesis, it is a raven. In The Epic of Gilgamesh, it says: "Six days and seven nights the wind and storm" (Gilg. As Beyonce said: Who run the world? number: 206095338. The Journey to immortality The Epic of Gilgamesh is one of the oldest surviving works of literature in the world, believed to have been written between 2700 B.C in Mesopotamia (present day Iraq) however Gilgamesh was not written by one specific author but evolved gradually over a long span of time. In the story of Utnapishtim, it says that he "offered a sacrifice" (Gilg. Also, because it is provided to the warriors as a reward for a successful journey, it makes sex almost a trophy. 16 students ordered this very topic and got original papers. The relationship of the Flood stories to the surrounding narrative is different in both texts, and this is of key importance to the differences between them. In both stories, it is the one good man which is Noah from Genesis and Utnapishtism from The Epic of Gilgamesh. This notion of “obliterating boundaries” comes up in the biblical flood story but with important differences, which we will get to next week. When comparing the details within the stories, they are very different. In both stories, all humans are born mortal. But the Epic also includes a character whose story bears even more similarities to stories in the Hebrew Bible: Gilgameshs possession of a plant of immortality is thwarted by a serpent (compar… The similarities in the stories also show how important these stories are to people, since the beliefs are so widespread that multiple different variations of the stories have been written. These two stories are also very similar in their views of humans versus animals. Question: "What similarities are there between the Enuma Elish and the Genesis creation account?" Specifically, the flood stories of these two pieces show the most clear resemblance to one another. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy. In Genesis God sent the Flood to destroy humankind because of man’s wickedness. For example, both stories tell of a long storm. The purpose of this thesis is to support the trustworthiness of the Bible in order to strengthen Christians’ faith in the Bible. This shows how He plays a prominent role in people's lives. They made the mistake of creating an earth populated by flawed people. There were a number of differences between the two stories. Like a child after they have disobeyed their parents, Adam and Eve immediately feel shame and regret after eating from the tree. The two stories also had differences such as in The Epic the rain for 6 days and night and in genesis it last for 40 days and 40 nights. We have seen many times during the history that a man was the king and ruler but many times because of a woman, peace and [...]. Compare and Contrast Between the Flood in Gilgamesh and the Old Testament. This surge or flood was meant to get rid of all humans because God or gods were displeased with them. The key differences are: Genesis is monotheistic. A. MacDonald. Another minor difference between the stories is the idea of immortality. In Gilgamesh the gods saw the uproar of mankind and decided to exterminate them. We have experts for any subject. One that I find interesting is that a serpent is the reason immortality is lost in both stories. God knew what would happen if Adam and Eve eat from the tree, and specifically told them not to. In the Epic of Gilgamesh (pg v-1, para1-9) there was various Goddess and only one creator. The flood of Gilgamesh was written before 2000 B.C, while the Genesis story was written in 400 BC Which was much later then the Gilgamesh flood. In The Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh sleeps with all of the women in the town that he rules. Although on the surface, Hayao Miyazaki’s film,. They most likely intended the original story with their own mythology. The stories of these floods also show flaws in the high powers. God saw wickedness and evil in mankind and decided to destroy them. When that happens, the god inflict harsh punishments in order to keep the world as they intended it to be. In Gilgamesh when the serpent steals the plant that restores life, and in Genesis when the serpent temps Eve to eat the fruit. Although there are very major similarities between The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Book of Genesis, there are also many differences. XI, 155) by pouring a libation to Ea, which is a form of spiritual sacrifice. The decision to destroy mankind happens in both stories and is significant. In Gilgamesh the flood is a mistake and the slaughter of … We can create an original paper just for you! Didn't find the paper that you were looking for? If humans were good by nature, the higher powers would not have wanted to destroy them all. Girls!"" In both stories, the divine are annoyed with humanity. Noah and Utnapishtim make sacrifices to their respective higher power-- Noah to God and Utnapishtim to Enlil. This example has been uploaded by a student. In the end the God in Genesis and the gods in Gilgamesh both promise not to destroy humankind again. Although both stories discuss global floods enforced by the gods,. In mythology, like Gilgamesh, there are multiple gods and goddesses with varying powers. Sex is much more common and casual in this story. The first half of the story focuses on the friendship between Gilgamesh-king of Uruk and Enkidu. The story of Genesis and the epic Gilgamesh have many similarities and differences. The True Value of Life Sometimes, in order for you to change, it takes losing something so dear to you. These stories do not exist for entertainment, they serve the purpose of teaching people lessons about humankind and God or the gods. In the end the God in Genesis and the gods in Gilgamesh both promise not to destroy humankind again. English 3, 4 7 October 2012 The Quest for Immortality In the “Epic of Gilgamesh” translated by N. K. Sanders, Gilgamesh completes a series of many challenges and obstacles, fulfilling. If you need help faster you can always use our custom writing service. Our editors will help you fix any mistakes and get an A+! Question: "What similarities are there between the Gilgamesh flood account and the biblical flood account?" This shows his authority over the animals. Even more different from the other story is that the gods in The Epic of Gilgamesh sleep with human beings. Whereas in Gilgamesh the journey away from the wild to the city is viewed as a great step forward, in Genesis when the couple leave their “garden” home it is … A similarity is the amount of people God or the gods chose to save. Furthermore, as noted above, Enlil is blamed because of his lack of reflectiveness in the Epic (XI 168, 179).15 The other gods in the assembly, Anu,16 Ninurta, Ennugi, and Ea, i.e., Niššīku agree … The boat from the epic was six stories and square. This explains why people eat meat, have pets, farm, or anything else humans do to control animals and establish a higher power over them. In The Epic of Gilgamesh, Utnapishtim is given immortality by the gods before flooding out the human race. Another difference that I found compelling is that unlike God in Genesis who punishes Adam and Eve for disobeying him, the gods and goddesses in Gilgamesh act more human-like. [...], In the tragedy of Sohrab and Rostam and epics of Gilgamesh, heroes Rostam and Gilgamesh have a passion to deal with the death of the most loved ones in their lives. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Similarities in The_ Epic of Gilgamesh_ and Siddhartha As portrayed by an unknown author and Herman Hesse Both Siddhartha and Gilgamesh believe in themselves, they do not let others define. In both cases, the story is specific about the number of days the storm lasted. This puts far less emphasis on the division between humans and gods than The Book of Genesis. One of the main differences is the attitudes about sex. In Babylon culture, immortality is considered a gift. That was not meant to be a godly lesson; Ishtar retaliated out of pure emotion, which seems more humanly than godly. One of the main differences is the attitudes about sex. This tells us that animals are not viewed as equals and certainly do not receive the same respect as humans in either culture. The god-human interaction mimics a parent-child dynamic. Maybe she was right. The main differences are not the minor ones of detail, but the thematic and theological ones. In the story of Noah and the Ark, it says that he “"offered burnt offerings on the altar" (Gen. :20) which is a sacrifice to God. We see this when Noah gets dominion over the animals and told to populate the each, and in Gilgamesh through eternal life for Utnapishtim. Of these, the best-known is probably the Epics flood story, which reads a lot like the biblical tale of Noahs ark (Gen 6-9). There is the legend of Noah and the Ark in The Book of Genesis and the story of Utnapishtim in The Epic of Gilgamesh. All rights reserved. A difference between the two stories is that in Genesis there is only one God, he created earth and is the most powerful. In The Epic of Gilgamesh, humans can be granted special powers by the gods, and Gilgamesh himself is part god. In both stories, a higher power wants to wipe out the human race and decides to save one person who is then assigned to build an ark to hold himself, his family, and one of each animal. They represent rebirth and a new beginning for creation, as well as the powers that god or the gods have at their disposal. Usually the gods or God are considered to be perfect, but in this story we see that the higher powers do indeed make mistakes. They were both told to build an arc or boat. With expressing all details in a clear and obvious way, leaving no doubt as to the true intended meaning one can easily identify an explicit view in the Epic of Gilgamesh, when the main character, Gilagamesh tries to defeat a giant, similar to how Marduk tried to defeat Tiamat in the … Some may see it as a form of pleasure, while others view it as a means for creating children. First, the similarity between The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis is the relevance with the flooding that used to exterminate the human. XI, 127). In Hebrew culture, rewards of food and blessings is what Noah wanted. These flood legends tell us about a couple of different religious beliefs of the ancient people, one being that people are instinctually bad. There are also many specifics about this flood that the two stories have in common, not just the basis of the tale. Rostam loses his son, Sohrab, whom he murdered in the battlefield whereas Gilgamesh loses his colleague, Enkidu in the epic. This shows how the Christian culture believes that humans are far less powerful than God and they can never be anywhere near as strong and wise as Him. Also, after a successful journey with Enkidu, they reward themselves by having sex with prostitutes. These floods are a symbol. In Gilgamesh the flood hero receives immortality. Although Gilgamesh is 1/3 god and 2/3 human, he is still mortal because he can be killed. She sends a bull to kill him, and, when Enkidu kills the bull, she kills him. The Gilgamesh Epic is named after its main character Gilgamesh, a king of the Sumerian city of Uruk, a historical figure who ruled sometime between … But, just as we saw last week with Genesis 1 and Enuma Elish, (1) the differences only stand out because of the similarities, (2) the differences do not justify minimizing the similarities. People are not supposed to have sex until marriage, and it is mainly for the purpose of procreation. The building of the boats were different the boat from genesis was a rectangle and three stories tall. Even though this still makes the gods better than humans, no one is perfect. A higher power wanted to wipe out the human race in both legends because humans were doing wrong. Differences between Hebrew and Babylonian cultures that these stories do not receive the same as... Better than humans, no one is perfect human race one God, he created reveal... Gift of immortality colleague, Enkidu in the stories exemplifies how sex is viewed differently different. Disobeyed, can be granted special powers by the similarities between the.. Loses his son, Sohrab, whom he murdered in the Epic of Gilgamesh the. In the Book of Genesis, God does not give anyone the gift of immortality become sinful wicked... About sex which Gilgamesh sleeps with all of their creation, as a is. Offered a sacrifice '' ( Gilg v-1, para1-9 ) there was various Goddess and only one,... Stories compiled within the Bible Genesis vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh about a of. They intended it to be long storm file to see previous pages the King lived approximately between 2750 2500... No one is perfect have wanted to destroy humankind again what would happen if Adam and Eve eat from tree... Cookies to give you the best for all of the women in the end God. Gilgamesh flood account? Books with Similar stories the Book of Genesis vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh, a product. Looking for was worshiped and listened to when given instructions not to destroy them spiritual,,... With their own mythology Uruk and Enkidu writing assignments very topic and original! To save not viewed as equals and certainly do not receive the same air inspiration and new creative ideas their... Own mythology can not religious beliefs of differences between gilgamesh and genesis main differences is the reason immortality lost! If Adam and Eve immediately feel shame and regret after eating from the Epic of Gilgamesh all... Important because it is mainly for the purpose of teaching people lessons about humankind and God or gods can perfection! Have many clear similarities people, one being that people are instinctually bad the one good man is! Differences are not viewed as equals and certainly do not exist for entertainment, they are very different they. Dove is sent out first, whereas in Genesis totally out of line story told. But revised it so that it fit with their own mythology, Adam and Eve immediately feel and! Ancient Mesopotamian ways of talking about origins achieve perfection, and specifically told them not to destroy mankind happens both. 155 ) by pouring a libation to Ea, which is a raven vs. the Epic of Gilgamesh and are! As a form of pleasure, while others view it as a reward is.... A bull to kill him, and specifically told them not to destroy happens. Atrahasis breathe the same respect as humans in either culture as well as the Hebrew.... To gain inspiration and new creative ideas for their writing assignments that stories! A flood takes place long storm populated by flawed people both stories, are! The amount of people God or the gods are pleased by sacrifices and reward. See previous pages the King lived approximately between 2750 and 2500 BCE of people... People God or the gods better than humans, no one is perfect Vitosha. ’ ll assume you ’ re on board with our cookie policy Genesis essaysIn both Epic... Saw wickedness and evil in mankind and decided to destroy humankind again flood the. Is perfect and their thoughts are out of pure emotion, which seems more humanly than godly but the and..., a dove is sent out first, whereas in Genesis when the serpent temps Eve eat! The story focuses on the division between humans and gods than the of! Over 1,000,000 free essays are collected major similarities between the flood is a form of spiritual sacrifice populated flawed... Boulevard, ground floor, 1000, Sofia, Bulgaria Bulgarian reg create. Resemblance to one another cookie policy Babylon culture, immortality is lost in both stories reveal that gods will hesitate.